Therapists need to have supervisors
Why? I sometimes see the world of emotions as miniature hurricanes or tornadoes. There are areas of our experience where we get caught up and swirled around. A therapist has had therapy whilst training to try to become aware of those mini powerful swirls of emotions, and to begin to work on them, see what they are about, where they come from. But you cannot just say once you have done your three years, or in my case over six years’ training, that you are sorted. You need a place to talk through your difficult clients, or your difficulties with clients.
Unconscious
And talking to someone else allows your own unconscious material to come to the surface. I might say to my supervisor, “To be honest I nearly fell asleep” (let’s say). OK, some of you will think this is ‘bad’. But if I am generally hard-working and conscientious; if I don’t usually fall asleep: then maybe it has a meaning. On my own, I may be too embarrassed to admit to myself what was happening. With a supervisor I trust, unconscious truth can come to the surface and together we can explore what it might mean. Falling asleep: was I bored? Why would I be bored with someone? Did they not reach out to me as they spoke? Why might they not try and connect? Do they believe deep down that people are not interested in them? Was that how it was for them as a child – carers did not try and tune in? And perhaps the child had to resort to a form of ‘showing off’ to try to get attention? Or doggedly ‘talking without relating’? It’s just one example. So being bored, or irritated, or turned on: all of them have meanings. Of course you don’t act out your feelings as a therapist. But with a supervisor you try to work out what those meanings are – to grow in your understanding of the inter-relational world of your client.
An approach to supervision
I am going to write from my perspective; so I am going to use ‘he’ as the supervisor. Let’s say he has a new group of therapists who are training.
How should a supervisor supervise?
1. Learning is painful. He should model an approach whereby he learns. There is nothing worse if in response to someone’s comment, the recipient responds immediately. Unless you know it already, you need to take time to hear what has been said and let it change you. It is painful not to know it all – to grow – to expand.
2. Honesty is painful. We all want to be angelic: thoughtful, patient, liking our clients unconditionally, unruffled… and so on. But we just aren’t. As I said, if we are honest, we get pissed off by clients sometimes, frustrated, distracted, charmed, lots of things. Half the time trainee therapists don’t want to mention that – they can find it desperately embarrassing. A supervisor needs to teach openly that we do feel these things as therapists and that if we dare admit it, those feelings can be clues to how our clients feel deep down.
3. “What did you say that for!” Supervision groups can be tough places. It’s like when you are ill – everyone becomes a doctor. When you are a trainee, everyone else would have said something more or different. A guy called Balint introduced a method (for doctors to start with) whereby one person talks about a patient and everyone else shuts up. When the presenter finishes, they shut up, even turn away from the group, and the others discuss the client without saying a word to the presenter, certainly no questions or critical comments, “Why didn’t you say that?”. The others talk about their feelings. The presenter just sits and listens. At the end, the presenter gets the chance to say more, to process what the others have said – and maybe has grown in their capacity to see different perspectives.
4. Parallel process. This may sound amazing. Say I am seeing a client whose mother thought he was stupid and whose father ignored him. I present him to my supervision group. They try to be nice to me, but they really don’t think I am doing very well – perhaps I have taken on a client too hard for me – perhaps I need to do some more training. One of the group embers finds it all so tedious they start replying to texts. So the client’s mother thinks the client is stupid – and the group thinks I am stupid. The father ignored the client; one person in the group ignores me as they text.
There can be a ‘parallel process’. What happens between therapist and client really can be duplicated between supervision group and the trainee who is presenting. One job of a supervisor is to be aware that that can happen. Honestly, it really can, it has happened to me when I have presented clients to others in a group several times.
But so what? Does that change anything even if it does happen? Well it makes the emotions real. Let’s be honest, if someone says their mum thought they were thick, you might say “Oh dear, I’m sorry,” and hardly mean it, hardly have any idea what it feels like. But then if someone in my supervision group thinks I am actually thick, I know how it feels all right. I feel wounded, angry… and so on. So to discover the parallel process in the group means that I can meet my client’s emotions full on. The job of the supervisor by the way is to use knowledge about the possibility of parallel process to reduce tension: “Anthony may feel hurt and irritated when he picks up that others feel that he isn’t up to much as a therapist; perhaps that’s exactly how the client felt when he was with his mother.”
So, supervision gives the therapist another vantage point to think about what is going on